100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Elizabeth O. - Verified Buyer
★★★★★
Very Aromatic
“This soap smells great and fills the bathroom with the loveliest scent. It lathers well and feels refreshing on my skin.”

As Seen In Women’s Health

We were featured in Women’s Health

Pretty Farm Girl was included in a June beauty feature highlighting natural skincare essentials.

Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Soap Made for Sensitive Skin Fragrance Free Handmade Tallow and Goat Milk Soap Bar

Pure, gentle, and deeply nourishing—this ultra-gentle bar is perfect for sensitive skin.

Made without fragrances or essential oils, this unscented bar cleanses while keeping skin soft and balanced.

  • Ultra-gentle & fragrance-free for sensitive skin
  • Deeply nourishes & soothes with buttermilk, goat milk & honey
  • Supports a healthy skin barrier with probiotic-rich kefir
  • Provides mild exfoliation with natural lactic acid

A simple, skin-loving cleanse—pure hydration without irritation.

$9.99

Our products are loved by 75,000+ Pretty Farm Girl customers for simple, natural beauty routines.

Key Benefits*

Cleanses without stripping moisture

Helps soothe dry, irritated skin

Made with goat milk, honey & kefir

Tax not included. Shipping calculated at checkout.

sensitive skin friendly

Trusted by Thousands

Secure Checkout

Free Shipping Over $75

Net wt 4.5oz | 127g Soap Bar

Tallow**, Aqua (Water), Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil*, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil*, Sodium Hydroxide^, Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil*, Goat’s Milk, Kaolin, Whole Dry Goat Milk, Goat’s Milk Kefir, Buttermilk, Mel (Honey)*#, Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera) Powder, Proprietary Probiotic Blend

*Organic
**Grass-Fed
^Turns oils into soap; none remains after saponification
#Naturally contains Propolis, Royal Jelly and Pollen

To use:

Run underwater and create a lather to wash the whole body.

Tallow**, Aqua (Water), Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil*, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil*, Sodium Hydroxide^, Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil*, Goat’s Milk, Kaolin, Whole Dry Goat Milk, Goat’s Milk Kefir, Buttermilk, Mel (Honey)*#, Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera) Powder, Proprietary Probiotic Blend

*Organic
**Grass-Fed
^Turns oils into soap; none remains after saponification
#Naturally contains Propolis, Royal Jelly and Pollen

Order Processing

We aim to process orders within 7 business days (Monday–Friday). Please note that we have no control over USPS transit times. Delivery routes and estimated arrival dates are subject to change due to weather, holidays, or other unforeseen circumstances. Any delays or route changes are the responsibility of USPS or UPS.

Expedited shipping methods (Priority, 3-day, 2-day shipping) only apply to the transit time once the package is with the mail carrier and do not speed up the order processing/fulfillment time.

Free Shipping

We offer free shipping within the U.S. and U.S. territories on orders over $75. This free shipping option will be sent via USPS Ground Advantage and does not include USPS Priority or UPS. Orders must total $75 or more after discounts are applied and before checkout to qualify.

Lost or Damaged Packages

Pretty Farm Girl offers Sustainability & Coverage from Corso as shipping protection. If your order is damaged, lost, or stolen and you have purchased this coverage, you may file a claim through Corso to receive a reorder or a refund. Please contact customerservice@prettyfarmgirl.com for assistance with these claims. Be sure to include your order details and any necessary photos of damaged items to complete the claim.If shipping protection is not purchased at checkout, you agree to take full responsibility for any lost, damaged, or undelivered packages. Failure to include the Insurance in your order will void a refund or replacement of lost or damaged orders.

If your order is lost or arrives damaged, please contact us within 30 days of your order date so we can assist you. If more than 30 days have passed since your order was placed, we are unable to offer a refund or replacement. 

Refunds

Due to the nature of our products, all purchases are final. We cannot accept refunds, exchanges, or returns.  

We provide a full ingredient list for every product. Please be sure to read it for any possible allergens before ordering. Pretty Farm Girl is inculpable for any adverse reaction or allergy to our products.

We understand that each person has a unique preference in scents and textures. However as a small handcrafted business we cannot offer returns or exchanges for a dislike of scents, textures, or colors. 

HEAT WARNING: From May - September, your body butter or face cream may arrive in a melted or runny consistency.

As our creams and body butters are whipped, this may result in the expected volume of the product appearing less than full. We assure you that we fill our jars completely to the top, however if you choose to purchase a body butter or face cream you are consenting to the possibility of it arriving in this reduced, melted, or runny state. 

We are doing as much as we can on our end to ship our body butters and face creams in a condition that will not melt.

The condition depends on where you live and the care of the postal team. We communicate directly with our postal pick up team, but cannot control the journey it takes to reach you.

We highly recommend selecting Priority Shipping at checkout for the fastest shipping transit time. (Please note that shipping time does not affect processing time to pack the order)

If your body butter arrives melted or runny, please put it in the refrigerator to re-solidify. 

The quality of the ingredients will remain intact even if the consistency is different than expected. 

Read our full refund and shipping policies for more information:

Shipping Policy

Return Policy

Your skincare routine

Where it fits in your routine

See exactly when and how to use this product.

Best used AM + PM
Frequency Daily
Step 1 Cleanse
Current
Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Soap Bar on a soft neutral background with product box
Soft + Gentle Buttermilk Soap Made for Sensitive Skin Fragrance Free Handmade Tallow and Goat Milk Soap Bar You are here
Step 2 Tone
Tone
Botanical Toner or Facial Mist
Step 3 Treat
Treat
Treatment Serum or Active
Step 4 Hydrate
Hydrate
Facial Oil or Hydrating Serum
Step 5 Seal & Nourish
Seal & Nourish
Face Balm or Facial Cream
Real Glow, Real Customer Experiences
See how customers are upgrading their daily skincare routine with relaxing red light therapy designed to support smoother, healthier-looking skin.
The Pretty Farm Girl Promise
Pure, skin-loving ingredients
Pure, skin-loving ingredients
Free from harsh additives
Free from harsh additives
No synthetic fragrances
No synthetic fragrances
Made in small batches
Made in small batches
From Dull & Uneven to Bright, Plump & Renewed

Layer your serum under your moisturizer for a complete, targeted routine that works while you sleep.

Lather
1
Lather

Work the bar into a rich lather between wet hands or a washcloth.

Cleanse
2
Cleanse

Gently massage over face or body and rinse thoroughly with warm water.

Feel
3
Feel

Skin feels clean — never tight, never dry. Just genuinely nourished.

ADD TO CART stars

4.8/5 based on 2,000+ happy customers
Simple Ingredients, Powerful Results
Every product in our kits is made with clean, real ingredients — no synthetics, no fillers, nothing you wouldn't want on your skin.
Tallow
Tallow

Tallow not only makes a great base for soap making, but it also has a range of benefits for your skin. Tallow is packed full of the same lipids that are needed for healthy skin. They help to ensure that moisture can move freely in and out of cells. Lipids also help to reduce infection, protect cell structure, keep in moisture and increase skin flexibility.

Buttermilk
Buttermilk

Rich in moisturizing properties, buttermilk soothes dryness and irritation while leaving the skin soft and hydrated. Buttermilk’s calming nature makes it ideal for sensitive or sun-damaged skin, restoring balance and radiance. Buttermilk also contains lactic acid, Vitamin A, and Vitamin D, promoting smoother and healthier skin.

Aloe Vera
Aloe Vera

Aloe is widely known for its soothing and hydrating properties, making it ideal for calming irritated or sensitive skin. It helps to lock in moisture, promoting soft, smooth skin. Rich in antioxidants and vitamins, aloe also supports skin healing, making it a popular choice for reducing redness and soothing skin.

ADD TO CART Stars

4.8/5 based on 2,000+ happy customers
background image background image
Created for Soft, Clean, Healthy-Looking Skin
Made with nourishing tallow, goat milk, honey, and probiotic kefir to gently cleanse while supporting soft, balanced, healthy-looking skin.
  • icon

    Cleanses without stripping natural moisture

  • icon

    Helps soothe dry, sensitive-looking skin

  • icon

    Rich in skin-loving nutrients & nourishing fats

  • icon

    Creamy lather with a clean, refreshing feel

  • icon

    No synthetic fragrances or harsh detergents

ADD TO CART star

4.8/5 based on 2,000+ happy customers
Why Your Skin Will Love Every Bar
Clean ingredients. Real suds. Zero compromise
Gentle on sensitive skin
Gentle on sensitive skin
Tallow and goat milk calm irritation while cleansing — ideal for eczema, rosacea, or reactive skin.
Naturally moisturizing lather
Naturally moisturizing lather
Unlike detergent-based soaps, ours maintain your skin's natural moisture barrier as they clean.
Zero harsh chemicals
Zero harsh chemicals
No SLS, no parabens, no synthetic fragrance — just clean, purposeful ingredients you can pronounce.
Discover the Difference in Every Ingredient
Not all skincare is made the same. See how our nourishing approach compares to conventional products.
ADD TO CART star

4.8/5 based on 2,000+ happy customers
comparison image comparison image
Cleansing That Actually Nourishes
Handcrafted with tallow and goat milk, our artisan soaps clean gently while replenishing the moisture most cleansers strip away.
Tallow + goat milk base
Tallow + goat milk base
A time-honored combination that cleans deeply while conditioning and soothing sensitive skin.
Small-batch handmade
Small-batch handmade
Each bar is cold-process crafted in Florida — no shortcuts, no mass-production compromises.
Fragrance-free options
Fragrance-free options
Gentle enough for eczema-prone, reactive, or baby-sensitive skin.
Long-lasting bars
Long-lasting bars
Dense, hard bars that last far longer than supermarket soaps — better for your skin and your wallet.
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Safe for Sensitive Skin
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
Fast Shipping & Easy Returns
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
100% Natural & Non-Toxic
Handmade in Small Batches
Handmade in Small Batches
Loved By Real Customers
See why so many people are making this part of their everyday skincare routine for softer, healthier-looking skin.

Overall rating: 4.9551725 / 5 from 290 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This handmade buttermilk soap bar, made with tallow and goat milk, is praised for its gentle effect on sensitive skin, clean and nourishing ingredients, and pleasant natural smell. Customers appreciate its quality and the divine lather it produces, though opinions on the bar size and price vary. Fast shipping is also noted.

Summary topics

  • Skin Softness: 18%
  • Natural Smell: 20%
  • Product Quality: 11%
  • Lather Quality: 4%
  • Ingredient Cleanliness: 6%

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "Great lather and scent is divine!" — Corrinne P.
  • "The soap feels luxurious and made my skin feel great initially." — Susan H.
  • "Smells incredibly natural and it is clearly made with high quality materials." — Margarett B.

Reviews

Proven wrong: A quality soap actually does matter

"I have very sensitive, dry, and eczema-prone skin. Whenever I’m experiencing a flare-up, I reach for this bar. I used to think that because soap is a 'wash-off' product, there was no point in investing in a high-quality one. I was wrong. This bar truly protects my skin and helps it heal faster. I had a painful flare-up on my hand, and while it's still visible, it has healed significantly after just two weeks of use."

— A. (5/5)

So gentle and comforting!

"I (and my skin) love this gentle soap. Cleans very well, yet is super gentle- feels like silk. It feels like a warm hug. This is going to be a recurring purchase!"

— Suanne M. (5/5)

"So gentle and calming- i love this soap!"

— Black (5/5)

This is such a wonderful bar of soap. Hon. . .

"This is such a wonderful bar of soap. Honestly, I wash my hands and they feel very clean. . . but also moisturized. I highly recommend this - not only for yourself, but it would be a great gift because it's something that the recipient would truly love and use."

— Gisselle B. (5/5)

Wife and I love the soaps. All are of exc. . .

"Wife and I love the soaps. All are of excellent quality."

— Constantin A. (5/5)

"Soft and i use it to shave and i never cut myself!"

— Mateo (5/5)

love quality and quantity of soap

"love quality and quantity of soap"

— Icie P. (5/5)

I love this soap!! It makes my skin feel s. . .

"I love this soap!! It makes my skin feel so clean, soft and smooth."

— Stephany S. (5/5)

I love these soaps. They lather great and. . .

"I love these soaps. They lather great and leave me al feeling so clean. And I know there isn't a bunch of random chemicals in it."

— Sadie W. (5/5)

This is the 2nd purchase for goats milk so. . .

"This is the 2nd purchase for goats milk soap for someone that has eczema. She loved the way it made her skin feel."

— Summer C. (5/5)

Q&A

Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know before you order.
Can I use these on my face?
open icon close icon
Yes. Our Soap Bars are made with gentle, nourishing ingredients and can be used for facial cleansing, especially the fragrance-free varieties. If your skin is very sensitive, we recommend starting with a small patch test first.
How long does a bar last?
open icon close icon
With proper care, one bar can last several weeks. To extend its life, keep it dry between uses and store it on a draining soap dish away from standing water.
Are these good for eczema or psoriasis?
open icon close icon
These bars are crafted with rich, skin-loving ingredients like tallow and milk to help cleanse without leaving the skin feeling stripped. For very sensitive skin, we recommend choosing a fragrance-free option and patch testing before regular use.
Do they lather well?
open icon close icon
Yes. These bars create a creamy, comforting lather that cleanses beautifully while still feeling soft and nourishing on the skin.
Are they safe for children?
open icon close icon
They are gentle enough for family use, but we recommend avoiding contact with the eyes and choosing fragrance-free options for younger children or sensitive skin. If your child has known allergies or skin concerns, patch test first or consult your healthcare provider.
How should I store my soap bar?
open icon close icon
For the best experience, allow your bar to dry fully between uses. A draining soap dish or soap saver will help preserve the texture, shape, and longevity of the bar.
What makes tallow soap different?
open icon close icon
Tallow gives the bar a rich, creamy feel and helps create a soft, conditioning cleanse. It’s a traditional, nutrient-rich ingredient that pairs beautifully with milk-based formulas for a gentle everyday soap.