Tallow Soaps vs Commercial Soaps
Last updated: Jan 21, 2025
Why Traditional Tallow Soap Is Better Than Commercial Soap
Words by
Jenn Keel
Follow us
Published on: Dec 17, 2024
The Natural Skincare Secret Your Great-Grandmother Already Knew
Walk through any beauty aisle and you’ll see shelves full of brightly colored body washes and heavily scented soap bars.
But here’s something most people don’t realize:
Many commercial soaps aren’t actually soap at all.
They are detergent-based cleansers made with synthetic ingredients that can strip the skin and disrupt your natural skin barrier.
That’s why more people today are switching back to traditional soap made with natural ingredients. 🌿
At Pretty Farm Girl, we believe skincare should go back to its roots using simple, nourishing ingredients your skin recognizes.
Let’s explore why handmade tallow soap is better than commercial soap and how it can transform the health of your skin.
Featured Product
Bar Soap
Blue Beauty Cream Facial Bar
$15
What Is Tallow Soap?
Handmade Tallow soap is made through a natural process called saponification, where natural fats and oils react with lye to create real soap.
Once the process is complete, the lye is no longer present, leaving behind a cleansing bar rich in skin-loving nutrients.
Natural handmade soap typically contains ingredients like:
🌿 Olive oil
🐄 Tallow (traditional skin-nourishing fat)
🌿 Coconut oil
🍯 Raw honey
🌿 Botanical extracts and essential oils
These ingredients have been used in skincare for centuries because they help cleanse the skin without stripping its natural moisture.
Tallow Salt Sea Soap Bar
Why Commercial Soap Can Be Harmful for Your Skin
Most commercial soap bars and body washes are actually synthetic detergents, not real soap.
They often contain ingredients such as:
• artificial fragrances
• sulfates and harsh surfactants
• synthetic preservatives
• petroleum-based ingredients
• dyes and fillers
These chemicals are designed to create foam, scent, and long shelf life, not necessarily to support healthy skin.
Over time, these ingredients can:
• dry out the skin
• weaken the skin barrier
• cause irritation or redness
• trigger headaches from synthetic fragrances
This is why many people notice their skin improves when switching to natural tallow soap.
5 Benefits of Natural Handmade Soap
1. Traditional Soap Protects Your Skin Barrier
Your skin barrier is responsible for keeping moisture in and irritants out.
Many commercial soaps strip away natural oils, leaving skin dry and vulnerable.
Traditional soap helps protect the skin barrier because it contains naturally occurring glycerin, which attracts moisture to the skin and helps keep it hydrated.
Commercial soap manufacturers often remove glycerin to sell it separately in lotions.
Traditional soap keeps it right where your skin needs it.
2. Natural Soap Contains Skin-Nourishing Ingredients
Farm-fresh inspired & natural soaps focuse on real ingredients that support skin health.
For example:
🐄 Tallow – rich in vitamins A, D, E, and K and extremely compatible with human skin
🌿 Olive Oil – deeply moisturizing and gentle for sensitive skin
🍯 Raw Honey – a natural humectant that attracts moisture
🌿 Botanicals – provide antioxidants and soothing benefits
Instead of chemicals that stress the skin, natural soaps feed your skin nutrients.
3. Farm-fresh Inspired Soap Is Naturally Moisturizing
Many people are surprised that traditional soap can actually make skin feel softer after washing.
This is because natural oils remain in the final soap bar, helping replenish moisture during cleansing.
Helping maintain hydration and prevent the tight, dry feeling many people experience after using commercial soap.
4. Handmade Soap Avoids Artificial Fragrance
Strong artificial fragrances are one of the most common triggers for skin irritation and headaches.
Commercial soaps often rely on synthetic fragrance blends that contain dozens of undisclosed chemicals.
Traditional soap instead uses light natural scents from essential oils or botanicals.
The result is a clean, gentle aroma that doesn’t overwhelm your skin or senses.
5. Better for Sensitive Skin
Because traditional soap uses fewer ingredients and avoids harsh detergents, it is often a better choice for people with sensitive skin.
Many people experience improvements in:
• dryness
• redness
• irritation
• skin sensitivity
when they switch to natural handmade soap.
The Bottom Line: Natural Soap vs Commercial Soap
When comparing traditional soap vs commercial soap, the difference comes down to one simple idea:
Simple ingredients vs synthetic chemicals.
Traditional soap offers:
✔ natural cleansing
✔ skin barrier protection
✔ nourishing ingredients
✔ gentle scents
✔ better hydration
Commercial soap often focuses on foam, fragrance, and shelf life instead of skin health.
That’s why many people are rediscovering the benefits of traditional handmade soap.
Sometimes the best skincare solution is the one people trusted long before modern chemicals existed.
Featured Product
Bar Soap
Blue Beauty Cream Facial Bar
$15
Share